Linux in the Classroom:
Theory and Test
Jeffrey B. Williams
Kansas State University
June 1, 2000
Abstract
School systems have been eager to adopt classroom computing to improve student learning. As computer systems age, and as new operating systems are introduced, the current computers may not seem adequate for the job of teaching. However, there are alternatives available to school districts which can use older computers, increase software reliability, and decrease both acquisition and administration costs. This paper serves as a brief introduction to the Linux operating system and how it may be integrated into the curriculum. It is based on two demonstration projects which were conducted during the Spring, 2000, semester by several Kansas State University doctoral students.
Background
The May 23, 2000, McPherson Sentinel in a first page story reported:
The Unified School District 418 Board of Education voted 4-3 against a a request by the district’s technology committee that the board accept a proposed four-year rotational lease plan to replace and upgrade district computers.
Assistant Superintendent Perry McCabe…said the district has invested considerable funds the past few years in upgrading its technology. Now, he said, the district needs to consider its responsibility to maintain and continue to upgrade that technology.
The district currently has 800 computers, printers, and scanners. The computers range from models that are six to seven years old to the most current line of I-Macs and G-4s.[1]
The McPherson school district is noted as being one of the top districts in the country. If such a district is having problems with upgrading and maintaining computers both in the classroom and in the offices, other districts must be facing the same problem. While we would like to see the latest hardware and software in each school district, we know that resources are limited. As computer budgets grow, other program budgets shrink. This is the reality of working with a limited resource such as money, space, and personnel.
Any use of computers in the classroom requires thought, planning, and leadership. We must first determine if the computer is the best tool for a given learning objective. As much as I hate to admit, sometimes computers simply are not the proper medium for teaching a given subject. You can’t use a computer to teach a student to play a violin or to improve the person to person, face to face skills of people. (Please see pages 115 to 120 of Evil Geniuses in a Nutshell[2] for a succinct example.)
If we decide to use a computer, we must properly plan for it’s integration into the classroom. Not only must we determine the hardware and software to purchase, but we must also evaluate the infrastructure which makes using the computer possible. Where do we put them? What kind of desks do we use? How do we share printers, scanners, and Internet connections? Does the building have enough power to run multiple computers? Can phone lines, network cable, and other communication links be easily installed?
Those are just the physical problems. What about technical support? How large a budget is allocated for teacher education? What is the plan for upgrade and replacement of obsolete and broken equipment? Who determines the software which will be used? Strong leadership is necessary for resolving the problems of computers in the classroom. Sometimes unpopular decisions must be made, especially ones concerning the level of technology which will be supported. The strong leader must also concern himself with the impact of his decisions outside the school. Can the lessons learned in the classroom be applied outside the school setting? Hardware and software decisions certainly can not be made in a vacuum.
For the rest of this paper I will contend for the following points.
- There is a place for technology in the classroom.
- Linux can be used as an alternative to combat hardware and software obsolescence, while maintaining a cutting edge technology program.
- Given the right programs and circumstances, Linux makes much more sense in an educational setting than other operating systems.
- No computer is user friendly, easy to use, or intuitive. The proper use of technology requires hard work by everyone involved, the school board, the principal, the teachers, the technical support team, and the students.
- It is the job of technology coordinators, concerned members of the community, and
interested staff to persuade school administration to implement Linux.
- One can not implement Linux just because it is cool. Linux must fulfill a given function otherwise it is just another useless computer.
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5